Ajansev — Freelance Pricing & Proposal Hub
IRS Form 2553 Comparison

S-Corp vs. LLC Tax Savings Calculator

See when electing S-Corp status (IRS Form 2553) saves enough 15.3% self-employment tax to outweigh payroll and Form 1120-S accounting overhead.

Business Profit & Payroll Assumptions

Net Annual S-Corp Advantage

+$5,019/yr

Elect S-Corp
Single-Member LLC SE Tax (15.3%)
$20,488
S-Corp FICA Tax (on W-2 Salary Only)
$9,945
Gross Payroll Tax Saved
$10,543
S-Corp Payroll & Filing Overhead
−$2,800
S-Corp K-1 Distribution (No SE Tax)
$72,228
S-Corp & 401(k)Recommended for Gusto Solo & S-Corp Payroll

Electing S-Corp or Opening a Solo 401(k)? Automate W-2 Owner Payroll

Running S-Corp W-2 payroll cleanly keeps your IRS reasonable compensation compliant. Once your freelance net profit passes ~$80,000/yr, paying yourself a reasonable W-2 salary via Gusto unlocks major SE tax savings and Solo 401(k) contributions.

Partner link · FTC Disclosure

See Gusto Plans

Typical Break-Even Threshold: ~$80,000+ Net Profit

Line ItemBenchmark ValueExplanation
$45,000 Net Profit ($32k Salary)Stay LLCSE tax savings do not cover ~$2,800 S-Corp payroll & 1120-S CPA fees
$145,000 Net Profit ($65k Salary)Elect S-CorpSaves thousands in FICA on $72k+ owner K-1 distributions net of overhead

How We Calculate This (Methodology & Sources)

Verified: 2026 IRS & State Schedules

A single-member LLC pays 15.3% SE tax (on 92.35% of net profit up to the Social Security cap), whereas an S-Corp pays 15.3% FICA strictly on your reasonable W-2 salary and distributes remaining profit via Schedule K-1 free of SE tax, minus payroll/filing costs.

  • Gross FICA Savings = Single-Member LLC SE Tax − S-Corp W-2 FICA
  • Net Annual Advantage = Total LLC Tax − (S-Corp FICA + Income Tax + Compliance Cost)

Frequently Asked Questions

When does switching from an LLC to an S-Corp make sense?

For most US solo consultants, the sweet spot begins around $80,000 to $100,000 in consistent annual net profit—where FICA tax savings cleanly exceed $2,000–$3,000 in annual payroll software and Form 1120-S CPA preparation costs.

What is a "reasonable salary" for an S-Corp owner?

The IRS requires paying yourself comparable market wages for the hours and services you perform before taking tax-advantaged K-1 distributions. Setting salary artificially low (like $10,000 on $200,000 profit) triggers audit risk.

Tax & Compliance

50-State 1099 Tax Calculator

IRS Schedule SE, federal brackets, QBI 20% deduction, state income taxes across all 50 states + DC, and Form 1040-ES quarterly deadlines.

Tax & Compliance

50-State Sales Tax Calculator

Calculate out-the-door prices with state + average county/city sales tax across all 50 states + DC, or extract pre-tax subtotals from receipts.

Tax & Compliance

Solo 401(k) vs. SEP-IRA

Maximize self-employed retirement deductions and calculate exact annual tax savings including age 50+ and 60–63 catch-up limits.

Tax & Compliance

Home Office & Mileage

Compare IRS Simplified ($5/sq ft) vs. Actual Expense home office deductions alongside standard business mileage tax savings.

Free US Freelancer Briefing

Get the US Freelance Tax & Rate Checklist (Free)

Receive quarterly IRS 1040-ES deadline reminders and updated US freelance pricing benchmarks. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.